Crescent Magazine

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Letters
Letters

Letters to the Editor

E-mail Print PDF
US, allies have lost the Afghan war

The WikiLeaks article in the last issue of Crescent (August 2010) confirms yet again that the US has lost the war in Afghanistan. Your reports have consistently said as much but I guess it takes a western source for most people to accept what is so obvious to those who care to reflect.

   Another revealing aspect of WikiLeaks is the targeted killing of people by American Special Forces as well as the CIA. These constitute war crimes. American officials have tried to dismiss these reports as “old news”. Why? They cover events up to December 2009. Official US statements are meant to confuse people. In recent weeks, the shocking picture of Aisha, an 18-year-old Afghan girl, was splashed on the cover of Time magazine (August 9) with the provocative title, “What will happen when Americans leave”.

   This was a lie and vicious propaganda. Time alleged the Taliban had cut the poor girl’s nose and ears. It was her father-in-law who had perpetrated the crime. For the record, it happened while the Americans are still there. They must bear responsibility for this crime rather than blame the Taliban in order to justify continued military presence, and therefore, crimes, in Afghanistan.

   Khalid Orakzai

   Peshawar, Pakistan
 
 

US-Zionist threats against Iran

The US and its Zionist masters continue to threaten Islamic Iran, even saying they will use nuclear weapons, unless it terminates its legitimate and peaceful nuclear program. Let us reverse the scenario. If Iran had threatened the US or Zionist Israel, it would be immediately denounced as a terrorist state. So why is it that the western media and indeed most apologetic Muslims in the US remain silent about such threats issued by the US and Israel against Iran but are quick to denounce Muslims who are alleged to have done something wrong somewhere? Such allegations often turn out to be completely false but they achieve their desired effect.

   It should be clear to every thinking person that the greatest threat to world peace comes not from Iran but from the warmongers in Washington and Tel Aviv. It is these people that are the real culprits and enemies of world peace. They should be arrested and put on trial for war crimes. Only then can there be some hope for peace in the world.

   Mustafa Ali

   Mississauga, ON, Canada
 
 
 

Appeal for help from Pakistan

Everybody is aware of the devastation the floods have caused in Pakistan. Entire villages from the north to the south have been wiped out and thousands of people have died. The most severely affected are once again the poor. They have been neglected by the government that is run by corrupt politicians who do not care for the well being of the people. Only Islamic charities are providing help. I appeal to all Pakistanis and Muslims in Canada and America to extend a helping hand to Islamic charities. Please do not give a single penny to the government. Most of this aid will be stolen, as it was during the 2005 earthquake.

   Nasir Mahmood

   Mardan, Pakistan
 
 

People’s generosity

The floods in Pakistan have once again shown how good-natured the people of Pakistan are. Almost everywhere, people have been extremely generous in giving help to the flood victims. In many mosques, donations are collected and prayers are offered after taraweeh in the month of Ramadan. We see that once again the ordinary people of Pakistan have come forward in a most remarkable and generous way. They are showing the true spirit of Ramadan.

   Syed Mumtaz Ahmed

   Lahore, Pakistan
 
 

Central Asian Muslims

I want to congratulate your magazine for providing more coverage of the Central Asian region. This is an important area and we need to know what is happening to our brothers and sisters in that part of the world. Sometimes, Muslims forget there are Muslims beyond the Middle East and Pakistan. I would request that you provide detailed reports about these neglected areas. Often, news coverage is dominated by crises in different parts of the world.

   Showkat Mirza

   Chicago, IL, US

 

Letters to the Editor

E-mail Print PDF
Obama throws in the towel to the Taliban

Now that America’s military defeat in Afghanistan is certain, Barack Obama is looking for an exit strategy. One reader who wishes to remain anonymous speculates on what Mr. Obama might write in his letter to Mullah Omar to secure a safe retreat. 
 
Mullah Omar
Amir al-Mumineen
Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan
Some cave near Spinbaldok
At the Afghan/Pakistan border

Respected Amir al-Mumineen,

Assalamu Alaikum. I hope you and the Taliban Shura are well.

I have been meaning to write to you for quite some time to talk about peace. War has gone on far too long between our two countries causing much suffering on both sides. I believe the time has come to make peace.

As the Holy Qur’an says in Surah al-Anfal, verse 61, “If they incline to peace, incline you also to peace, and have trust in Allah.”

I propose to bring a nanawati jirga to Afghanistan. To demonstrate our sincerity, we have already taken certain steps that I hope will meet with your approval. Congress has been instructed to change the name of the United States to the Islamic Emirate of America. Once this is done, Congress will be called the Loya Jirga. In the meantime, we will be paying jizyah to the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan.

Effective immediately, our cabinet is to be called the Washington Shura. All cabinet as well as military posts have been abolished. Henceforth, everyone will be called a “Mullah” and nobody will shave his beard. Khanam Clinton is the only exception, for obvious reasons. But I have had a long chat with her and she has assured me that she will stop shaving her legs. She will also don the burqa in keeping with the best Afghan tradition. Since she is fond of blue colour, Khanam Clinton has requested I seek your permission for her to wear a blue burqa. When she joins me for the nanawati jirga, she will not open her big mouth in your presence. In fact, she will sit behind a curtain so as not to be visible.

I have also spoken to Mullah Clinton and told him to rectify his errant ways. I have warned him that Afghanistan is full of stones and there are enough to take care of him. Besides, when we declare America as the Islamic Emirate, there will be no room for such behaviour. If he persists, he will be taking a very big risk.

You would have noticed that I have taken other steps as well. Mullah McChrystal has been replaced by Mullah Petraeus. Mullah McChrystal was getting too close to Hamid Karzai and K2. This last does not refer to the high mountain in Pakistan; it is a title our boys have given to Ahmed Wali Karzai although I am sure K2’s corruption outstrips the mountain’s height.

We had a little crisis when people started adopting the Mullah title. There was argument between Bernanke and Geithner. Both wanted to be called Mullah Moola; Bernanke won handily because he already has a beard; besides, he controls all the moola.

We have been scouring around to buy shalwar kameez, patkai and pattoos. We want to be dressed properly when we arrive in Afghanistan. To our dismay, we discovered that the Afghans in Washington and New York do not own clothing stores; they run restaurants and make delicious rice and kebab. The Pakistanis have cornered the market on clothing. It is amazing how smart these Pakistanis are: during jihad against the Soviets, they made tons of money by insisting all of it be routed through them. Now Pakistani storeowners have made a killing selling us shalwar kameez, patkai and pattoos.

When we come for the nanawati jirga, I will bring four lambs and a Montana goat with me on Air Force One. I and Mullah Petraeus will sacrifice two lambs each at your feet. I have been informed that Amir al-Mumineen is fond of goat milk. You will love the Montana goat’s milk; its cheese is even more delicious.

My Muslim advisor, Rashad Hussain, tells me that there can be only one khalifah of the Muslims at a time. Would it be agreeable to Amir al-Mumineen if I were to take the title of Naib-e Khalifah?

Now I have just one small favour to ask: allow our troops to leave Afghanistan without being skinned alive. They will leave behind not only their weapons but also their boots. Please allow them to keep their pants on. I hope this meets with your approval.

Assuring you of my highest considerations and respect, I remain, 

Yours
Mullah Barack Obama
Prospective Naib-e Khalifah of
The soon to be, Islamic Emirate of America 

 

Letters to the Editor

E-mail Print PDF
Excellent analysis by Abu Dharr

I am a long time subscriber of your wonderful magazine Crescent Interna-tional. Its commentaries are informative and your writers cover a broad range of stories that are not usually available in the Western media. Even when they are reported, the bias in Western media reports is extremely disappointing. So I want to thank you for the great job you are doing.

I want to compliment Abu Dharr on his wonderful commentaries. His last column, A brotherly reminder to internal opponents of the Islamic State, (Crescent, February 2010) was not only brilliant but also extremely moving. I read it several times and each time I discovered a new perspective. He has a remarkable gift of presenting facts in a way that penetrate the heart.

   He put his finger on the issue by asking, “…why did one million Muslims give their lives in the first decade of the Islamic Revolution? Why did the prime minister of that time refuse, on a visit to Turkey, to go to Mustafa Kemal’s grave and follow protocol?” These are questions that our brothers taking to the streets in Iran should ponder over and answer. Do they want to be in the company of the likes of Karim Sadjadpour, Massoud Rajavi, Trita Parsi and Ray Takeyh or on the side of the mustadafin in Iran? I pray these brothers will not fall for Western propaganda, especially the US. Uncle Sam can never be a friend of Muslims, make no mistake about it.

Abu Bakr Mahamoud
 Chicago, IL, US
 

Russia and the North Caucasus

Thank you for highlighting ‘Russia’s imperial policies in the North Caucasus’ (February 2010). Crescent International was one of the principal sources of news on the region when the Chechen resistance was at its peak in the mid-nineties. In recent years, this coverage had declined somewhat but Br. Maksud Djavadov has brought out some interesting perspectives that would benefit all Muslims.

There are a lot of Muslims in Central Asia and the Caucasus region. We need to know what is happening there. It was also good to read Sister Zainab Cheema’s report on Eurasia’s energy wars… and Muslims in Pipelineistan.  She is a very good writer and a great addition to Crescent contributors. I hope we will see her write more often. It is also good to note that you are encouraging sisters to become involved. We need more sisters like Sister Zainab. Thank you for the great work.

   Mohamed Ali
   Victoria, BC, Canada
 
 
US should change policies

I would like to join Br. Farouk Nsamba of Kampala, Uganda, in urging the US to make a paradigm shift (Letters, February 2010). This is sound advice and Barack Obama should heed it if he wants to restore America’s image globally. Here in Kenya, many people were very enthusiastic when Obama became president. Many Kenyans also applauded his Kenyan roots. But now, it seems Obama is following the same policies as Bush.

I do not think Obama is stupid; he is very smart but the people around him are misleading him. He should realize that history will judge him, not his advisors. So whatever decisions he takes, good or bad, will be used to judge him.

   Abdullahi Odinga,
   Nairobi, Kenya
 
Pakistan’s plight

On March 23, Pakistanis will celebrate 70 years of the “Pakistan Resolution” passed in Lahore. It was indeed a historic moment. There was much jubilation and Muslims in British colonial India were enthusiastic. Pakistan was created on August 14, 1947 but what has it to show for itself since then? There is total chaos in Pakistan; the army is fighting its own people; corruption is at an all time high and prices have skyrocketed. Life for the average person is miserable. Did the people make the necessary sacrifices to create this kind of Pakistan?

Khalid Mahmoud Khattak
Peshawar, Pakistan
 
US homeless

Who would have imagined that there would be so many homeless people in the US, a country with the largest GDP in the world? Equally shocking, there are so many war veterans that also find themselves on the street. If these people are good enough to fight and die for America and protect its “values”, why are they abandoned when they return home? US unemployment rate at 10% is actually 30% among the poorest people while Obama has given nearly one trillion dollars to the banks.

Chris Van Clees
Orange County, CA, US
 

Letters to the Editor

E-mail Print PDF

 Western media and Islamophobia

It is good to see Crescent International tackle issues like the role of Western media in promoting Islamophobia (November 2009). The lie about media freedom in the West is peddled so often and with such persistence that even its victims — primarily Muslims — are taken in by it.

   The corporate-owned and controlled media does not care even for American or British citizens whose lives are directly affected by the policies of their governments so why should they care about Muslims who are perceived as the enemy? The concentration of media ownership in the hands of a few, mostly Zionists, is also extremely troubling.

   This begs the question: what should Muslims do to address the problem? It is unrealistic to expect that Muslim governments will tackle it because they are part of the problem. The West’s brutal policies against Muslims and the Islamic movement would not succeed but for the help provided by the illegitimate regimes in the Muslim world. Is it realistic to assume that regimes in Egypt or Pakistan would confront the US or Britain on whose goodwill the illegitimate rulers of these countries depend? In Pakistan, many journalists, ministers, bureaucrats, generals (both serving and retired) and academics are on the US payroll and busy promoting its agenda.

Shakir Imam
Mississauga, ON, Canada

Death of the wrong Thatcher

The contrived grief of Britain-doting Canadian royalists turned real upon learning that “Thatcher has died.” The Blackberry message was received at a November 10 black tie dinner attended by some 2,000 Conservatives to honour Canadian military families. The Iron Lady (Dragon Lady for some) of British politics is much revered by Canadian royalists.

While nobody choked on the five-course meal, Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper immediately dispatched his advisor to call Buckingham Palace and 10 Downing Street to confirm that Thatcher was indeed dead. A palace official sighed: “I wish it were true!”

It turned out the message was sent by Canadian Transport Minister John Baird from his home in Toronto to a person at the gala dinner to say his beloved 16-year-old grey tabby cat, named after Margaret Thatcher, had died. Cats may not have nine lives, but 84-year-old Maggie surely does. Endowed with an acerbic tongue that continues to wag amid a formidable set of teeth reinforced by canines that would make a pit bull blush with envy, Maggie lives. What a pity!

Tanvir Ahmed
 Toronto, ON. Canada   

 

South African odyssey

I greatly enjoyed reading Sister Zainab Cheema’s travelogue about South Africa (Crescen,t Nov. 2009). Her narrative was captivating with the right mix of politics and social charm. While Crescent is best known for its hard-hitting commentaries and tales of sufferings of Muslims worldwide, which makes it unique among Muslim publications, it is also refreshing to see a lighter touch. I hope Sister Zainab will continue to contribute to the magazine to increase the variety of stories available in its pages. What I have heard about the hospitality of the South African Muslim community is confirmed by her.

Sabira Jeevani
Abu Dhabi, UAE   

 

Turkey makes its move

It is good to read that Turkey is once again beginning to assume a leading role in the Muslim world. It is an important country with a glorious history. Unfortunately, Kemalism des-troyed the prestige it had acquired as a result of being a Muslim power even if not entirely an Islamic power. Kemal-ism turned it into the sick man of Europe. Turkey should abandon its quest to join the European Union. The racist Europeans will never accept it. Why not stick to the Muslim world where it will enjoy its rightful place as a leading member of the Ummah?

  Selim Pasha
New York, NY, US
 
 

Zardari’s exit?

With the demise of the National Reconciliation Ordinance (NRO), can we look forward to the end of Asif Zardari’s rule? The man’s character is so low that it is a disgrace for him to be president of a country calling itself the “Islamic Republic”. It is Pakistan’s tra-gedy that one terrible ruler is replaced by another. Unless the people of Pak-istan rise up to take charge, nothing will change. Instead of looking for saviours, people should look to themselves.

Javed Ahmed Khan
 Lahore, Pakistan  


 




We have 16 guests online